La Cantina Bay in Bayville

We love this place. Unfortunately, no longer BYOB; nevertheless, still friendly family owned, with a delicious Italian & Mexican menu. The view of the LI Sound is spectacular. We has fajitas, and the special paella was very good ($40). We will miss the BYOB but understand the change, the house margaritas were authentic and very good. The staff and service is excellent and friendly.

Love the food

Homemade.

Outstanding food - both Mexican and Italian. Very friendly, helpful staff.

Small, casual Mexican restaurant with very good food & generous portions.

Cinco de Mayo celebration:Guitarist singing Mexican classic tunes/ Margaritas/Food/Service top notch

Great menu and the nicest family runs the restaurant. They are tripping over themselves to make you happy. Great service and magnificent food.

Had a awesome experience in this spot with my wife. The food comes quick and the customer service is just great. Prices are affordable.

I actually enjoy their food and service, good area to where I live. The cashiers are always welcoming. Highly recommended.

Great meal and great customer service

Family restaurant with good food and friendly service

I eat here a lot since I work close by. I must say their customer service is always great and they keep the place well kept constantly. Rates are convenient and they serve generous portions.

Friendly people, good staff and good food. Enjoy it.

Excellent as always! Warm, cozy and delicious, a true family labor of love. Great mexican and italian cuisine with birds eye view of long island

Delicious food. Friendly staff.

food

Supper nice people and GREAT food! A good excuse to go to Bayville and have lunch or dinner in a beautiful place. Sit by the picture windows, look at the LI Sound and watch the world go by.